Third Party Risk Assessment

A third party risk assessment is an assessment of the risks posed by external vendors to your organization. It highlights the vulnerabilities and mitigates the risks through a comprehensive vendor risk management program.

This article will cover the components, evaluation methods, risk mitigation strategies and best practices to ensure secure vendor relationships.

Summary

• Third party risk assessments are a must for organizations to identify vulnerabilities and mitigate operational, reputational, financial and compliance risks associated with external vendors.
• Components of third party risk assessments include identifying critical vendors, evaluating them through thorough due diligence and using standardized risk assessment questionnaires to gather the information. It is also crucial to evaluate risks associated with business partners to ensure comprehensive risk management.
• Ongoing monitoring and regular reassessments are key to keeping your vendor risk profile up to date and using technology and collaboration can make third party risk management so much more effective.

What is Third Party Risk Assessment?

Third party risk assessment is a key part of a risk management program as it involves evaluating the risks of engaging with external vendors, suppliers or service providers. This assessment helps organizations identify the vulnerabilities and mitigate the risks before they can cause harm.

A vendor risk management program is crucial for addressing various types of risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks.

Third party risk management (TPRM) includes all types of third parties and the risks they pose to an organization. It’s about protecting against all forms of risk – operational, reputational, financial and compliance risk. Thorough third party risk assessments help organizations avoid costly surprises and have secure, reliable vendor relationships.

Not doing these assessments can have serious regulatory and reputational consequences. For example a data breach caused by a vendor’s poor security practices can damage your organization’s reputation and result in big fines. So understanding all types of risk is key to a world class TPRM program.

Components of a Third Party Risk Assessment

Effective third party risk management means focusing on the key components – identifying critical vendors, evaluating vendor risk and creating a comprehensive risk assessment questionnaire. It is also crucial to evaluate and mitigate risks associated with business partners to ensure a robust risk management strategy.

Each step is important for a thorough third party risk management strategy.

Identifying Critical Vendors

The first step in the third party risk assessment process is identifying critical vendors and business partners, setting the foundation for evaluating the risks. This starts with inventorying all current third parties to understand the scope of your vendor relationships. Critical vendors can be identified using relationship questionnaires and surface level attack surface scanning to determine their level of criticality.

Vendors are typically segmented into three tiers based on their criticality – Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3. The tier is determined by factors such as inherent risk scores, impact on operations and contract value. Segmenting vendors in this way helps to prioritize risk management and ensures the most critical vendors get the attention they need.

By understanding external vendor relationships organizations can quantify the risks based on the impact and focus on the most critical ones. This reduces the scope to the regulatory risk category for critical vendors and simplifies the risk assessment process.

Evaluating Vendor Risk

Once you have identified critical vendors the next step is to evaluate the risks they pose – their financial stability and security practices. Key areas to look at include data security, geographical location, compliance history and incident recovery processes. A comprehensive vendor risk management program is essential for addressing various types of risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks.

Due diligence is key to evaluating the risks associated with each vendor. This includes researching the vendor’s security processes, compliance history and client support services. Contracts should clearly outline the compliance requirements relevant to the third party so they adhere to the necessary regulations.

During annual risk reviews data security, compliance with regulations and new risks should be assessed to keep the risk profile up to date. A thorough risk assessment helps organizations choose reliable and secure partners and reduces the vulnerabilities.

Risk Assessment Questionnaires

Creating a third party risk assessment questionnaire is key to identifying weaknesses in vendors and partners by gathering detailed information about their services, data security and data handling practices. It is also important to gather detailed information about business partners' services and practices to ensure thorough risk evaluation.

The risk assessment questionnaire should uncover the vendors’ policies, processes and procedures. Avoid freeform questions to ensure clarity and consistency in responses. Relevant regulations for third party vendors can be determined through supplier risk assessment relationship questionnaire submissions or compliance data collected.

Organizations should create standard risk assessment and questionnaire templates to make the assessment process easier. The questionnaires will identify the gaps between a vendor’s security controls and regulatory requirements and provide valuable insight into areas to improve. Vendors may need to involve multiple people and documentation in completing the vendor risk assessments to get comprehensive and accurate responses.

The Risk Assessment Process

The risk assessment process involves several steps – gathering data from vendors, analyzing the assessment results and mitigating the risks. Each step ensures a thorough third party risk evaluation and risk management.

A comprehensive vendor risk management program is essential for addressing various types of risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks.

Gathering Data from Vendors

Gathering data from vendors and business partners is key to the risk assessment process. Common methods include third party risk exchange, spreadsheets and assessment automation software. Tools can speed up the evidence gathering process by simplifying data collection and compliance monitoring.

Ask specific questions about incident recovery processes, security practices and financial stability when assessing third parties. Surface level attack surface scanning can also reveal security risks in a vendor’s attack surface and provide valuable insight into the vulnerabilities.

Automation helps with third party risk management by simplifying data collection, risk assessment and compliance monitoring. This not only speeds up the process but also ensures the data collected is accurate and up to date so better risk management decisions can be made.

Analyze the Results

Analyze the assessment results. A risk matrix with impact and likelihood axes helps to focus on the most critical risks and audits. The Y axis is the likelihood of the event happening, the X axis is the impact. A comprehensive vendor risk management program is essential for addressing various types of risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks.

After analyzing the results, assign a risk rating to each vendor based on their risk and performance. This will help you prioritize which vendors need attention now and which are lower risk. Review the vendor’s answers and analyze the results thoroughly to ensure all risks are identified and mitigated.

Based on the analysis organizations should decide on a risk management approach that aligns to their risk appetite and business objectives. This may mean adding more controls, increasing monitoring or even terminating the vendor relationship if the risks are too high.

Mitigate the Risks

Mitigating the risks is a key part of third party risk management. While you can’t eliminate all vendor risks, you must manage and mitigate them proactively. This means finding partners that can minimize downtime and restore services without compromising security. It is also crucial to evaluate and mitigate risks associated with business partners, ensuring thorough documentation and assessment processes to identify specific risks.

In high risk vendor relationships you may need to remove the vendor altogether to protect the organization. Security teams should be aware of the controls to mitigate third party risks and regularly check a vendor’s financial health for signs of distress.

Putting in place security controls and regularly checking a vendor’s financial health will help mitigate the risks and ensure business continuity. This is key to a secure and resilient third party ecosystem.

Ongoing Monitoring and Re-assessment

Ongoing monitoring and re-assessment is key to a third party risk management strategy. Continuous monitoring helps organizations adapt to changes in vendor risk profiles and address new risks quickly.

A comprehensive vendor risk management program is essential for ongoing monitoring and re-assessment, ensuring that all potential risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks, are understood and mitigated.

Continuous Monitoring

Continuous monitoring is critical to identify and address emerging risks associated with third party relationships and business partners before they get out of control. Continuous oversight of third party activity allows organizations to manage risks proactively and prevent big problems, like ransomware attacks.

The third party risk assessment is not a one off event but requires continuous oversight to be effective. Ongoing monitoring and due diligence is needed for overall third party risk management so that any changes to the vendor’s or business partner’s risk profile are addressed quickly.

Data breaches and subcontracting services may change a supplier’s risk score so continuous monitoring is key to keeping the risk profile up to date.

Reassess Regularly

Re-assess regularly to keep risk profiles current. Critical vendors should be reassessed at least once a year. Annual audits should cover compliance to regulations and new cyber security threats that may have arisen so the risk profile remains current. A comprehensive vendor risk management program is essential for addressing various types of risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks.

Re-assessments keep organizations informed of changes to the vendors’ operations or risk profiles so they can make timely and informed decisions about their third party relationships. This proactive approach means potential risks are identified and mitigated before they cause damage.

Third Party Risk Management Best Practices

Best practices will help you with third party risk management. These will help you with compliance, reduce regulatory risk and maintain secure and reliable vendor relationships. It is also crucial to evaluate and mitigate risks associated with business partners, ensuring thorough documentation and assessment processes to identify and manage specific risks effectively.

Technology and Automation

Technology and automation will help you with efficiency and effectiveness of third party risk management. Tools like START allow you to create controls and questionnaires, have a single source of truth, monitor the process and send automated reminders. These tools are designed to keep up with industry needs, regulations and the threat intelligence landscape so you are always prepared.

In 2023, 41% stated time as the primary challenge, with lack of personnel to perform assessments as the secondary. A vendor risk management program can leverage these technologies to automate and streamline the process.

“Back when our security organization was still new, threat intelligence was a capability we knew we wanted to purchase”says Kyriba Senior Manager, Cyber Security Kyle Abbey.

Focus on automating the repeatable parts of TPRM. Start small and automate the key tasks and you can build up your risk management program over time.

Using risk intelligence tools helps you identify emerging risks associated with third party vendors, so you can manage risk proactively.

Working with Vendors

Working with vendors and business partners is key to third party risk management. Good communication between an organization and its vendors will improve overall risk management outcomes. Simplified collaboration will avoid delays in risk assessments and reduce the likelihood of breaches so both parties are aligned on risk management.

Working together means vendors know what is expected of them and commit to high standards. This will improve risk management outcomes and strengthen the overall partnership and create a more resilient and secure third party ecosystem.

What Happens If You Ignore Third Party Risk Assessments

Ignoring third party risk assessments can have big consequences for organizations. Legal liabilities can arise from regulatory non compliance due to third party activity and result in big fines and penalties. Neglecting these risks can have big financial risk consequences including unexpected costs from vendor failures and business disruption.

The reputational damage from third party incidents cannot be underestimated. A data breach from a vendor’s poor security will damage an organization’s reputation, public perception and stakeholder trust. These incidents can have long term effects and it can be hard to recover and get back in the market.

Operational disruption from third party failures can have a critical impact on business continuity and productivity. These can result in significant downtime and the organization’s ability to deliver services and meet customer expectations. So proactive third party risk management is key to mitigating these supply chain risks and the organization’s resilience. Implementing a comprehensive vendor risk management program is essential to prevent these consequences and ensure all potential risks associated with vendors are understood and mitigated.

Third Party Risk Management Program

Building a TPRM program involves key steps like defining roles and responsibilities and a structured risk management framework. These are critical to third party risk being managed and mitigated.

It is also essential to include business partners in the third party risk management program to ensure comprehensive risk evaluation and mitigation.

Roles and Responsibilities

Clear roles and responsibilities are key to third party risk management, including the evaluation and mitigation of risks associated with business partners. Executive support is required to manage third party risk across the organization so the necessary resources and attention is given to this important task. Contracts with external partners should clearly state areas of responsibility so there is no misunderstanding and accountability.

Different departments including vendor management teams have a role to play in third party risk management. By defining these roles and ensuring each department knows their role, organizations can create a cohesive risk management strategy that covers all aspects of third party risk.

Risk Management Framework

A structured risk management framework is key to managing risks associated with third party vendors. This should include identifying critical vendors, assessing the risk and implementing mitigation. A good risk management framework will help you anticipate, respond to and mitigate third party risk. A vendor risk management program, often referred to as a third party risk management program, is crucial for addressing various types of risks, including operational, reputational, financial, and compliance risks.

Vendor Risk Management examples will give you insights into how to do the evaluations so you can build a comprehensive TPRM program and keep your third party relationships secure and resilient.

FAQs

What is a third party risk assessment?

A third party risk assessment is an evaluation of the risks associated with external vendors, suppliers or service providers and is key to third party risk management. Proper assessment will help you mitigate threats to your operations and reputation.

Why do I need to identify critical vendors?

Identifying critical vendors is key to prioritizing risk management so you can allocate resources to the vendors that have the biggest impact on your operations. This will reduce disruption and increase overall business resilience.

How do I get data from vendors?

You can get data from vendors using tools, assessment automation software and spreadsheets to make the process easier. These will help you manage your vendor data better.

What happens if I ignore third party risk assessments?

Ignoring third party risk assessments will result in legal liabilities and financial losses, reputational damage and operational disruption. You need to know these risks to protect yourself.

How does technology and automation help?

Technology and automation will help with data collection, risk assessments and compliance monitoring.

Wrapping up

In summary, third party risk management is key to security, compliance and resilience of an organization. By understanding third party risk assessments and following a structured process you can identify, evaluate and mitigate the risks of your vendor relationships. Key to this process is identifying critical vendors, evaluating vendor risk and creating comprehensive risk assessment questionnaires. It is also crucial to include business partners in your overall risk management strategy to ensure thorough documentation and assessment processes.

Do the risk assessments and use tools like risk matrices to prioritize your risk management and develop strategies. Proactive risk mitigation, ongoing monitoring and regular re-assessments are key to keeping your risk profile up to date and addressing emerging risks quickly.

Implementing best practices such as using technology and automation and collaborating with vendors will further strengthen your third party risk management program. By building a TPRM program with clear roles and responsibilities and a structured risk management framework you can protect your operations, reputation and financial stability from third party threats.

Don’t wait until it’s too late—experience the power of Recorded Future’s threat intelligence platform. Request a demo today and see how you can turn data into actionable insights that protect your organization from third party risks.